Editorial Learnings

Context: Back in 2016, I was packing up to leave a symposium in Dublin feeling quite chuffed/relieved after my presentation had gone well earlier on in the day, when I heard my name being called by a familiar voice. I turned my head to see a real hero of mine beckoning me to join a group gathered in the corner of the room, by the front of the main stage. Unknown to me, the AISHE AGM just about to begin, and here I was, unexpectedly sitting amongst some big names in the field (honestly, at that time I felt as excited as I did back on day 1 of college!). AISHE = The All Ireland Society for Higher Education.
To cut a long story short, I ended up being nominated and seconded to formally join the AISHE executive committee. So in 2016, several years after starting my journey in teaching and learning I was joining the All Ireland Society for Higher Education. What a feeling! I had published in their journal a few times, and felt this was an unbelievable opportunity, and what incredible colleagues to join up with. I have such fond memories of our committee meetings, normally held in Dublin and/or various locations. Always inspiring, always future focused, always keen to support the HE sector across the island.
A few years later, in 2019, I had the opportunity to join the editorial board at AISHE-J, the society's 'All Ireland Journal for Higher Education', and having recently made the difficult decision to step back from this role due to other commitments, I wanted to reflect and document this period of incredible personal and professional growth....as well as highlight some key learnings from being in an editorial role with a successful journal.
To cut a long story short, I ended up being nominated and seconded to formally join the AISHE executive committee. So in 2016, several years after starting my journey in teaching and learning I was joining the All Ireland Society for Higher Education. What a feeling! I had published in their journal a few times, and felt this was an unbelievable opportunity, and what incredible colleagues to join up with. I have such fond memories of our committee meetings, normally held in Dublin and/or various locations. Always inspiring, always future focused, always keen to support the HE sector across the island.
A few years later, in 2019, I had the opportunity to join the editorial board at AISHE-J, the society's 'All Ireland Journal for Higher Education', and having recently made the difficult decision to step back from this role due to other commitments, I wanted to reflect and document this period of incredible personal and professional growth....as well as highlight some key learnings from being in an editorial role with a successful journal.
Hence, some personal reflections on being a member of an editorial board are forthcoming….
1. Teamwork
It’s key for everything, isn’t it? Being an editor is really helped by the team attitude present. You sometimes need to talk through an issue, gain another perspective or be motivated by your teammates. For me, I always felt that team ethos at AISHE & AISHE-J. Being aware of this history of the journal, those who had established it initially, or come before you on the same team were always motivating factors too. Working as an editorial team, and seeing an issue come together and publish on time to the sector is quite a proud feeling too. Good teamwork really does makes the dream work.

2. Commitment
Working with AISHE and AISHE-J is on a voluntary basis, so it does add to your workload…but in a good way as it is very rewarding to know you are part of a momentum to support the HE sector across Ireland. Sustaining an avenue for sectoral colleagues to be able to publish and share their research, reflections and expertise does drive you on. With regard to a submission, there is a process to follow and while some steps can take time, the peak of the workload often comes around the month of the publication itself (the journal publishes 3 times per year; June, Oct, Feb). For every editor at every journal, you may need to consider your evenings coming up to, or in or around, publication time, but the reward is in helping others and supporting the HE sector.

3. Reviewers, gratitude & kindness
As an editor, you do get to meet wonderful reviewers who are extremely kind and generous with their time, all while being anonymous and doing their work behind the scenes constructively supporting the authors. At AISHE-J, we have a very large collection of dedicated reviewers who we invite from time to time, bearing in mind their number of ongoing/prior reviews etc., and cognisant that their workload at the time may not permit them to engage on some occasions. Reviewers provided blinded, independent reviews on submissions, which themselves are also blinded.

4. Inspiring authors
Innovative, honest, thorough, cutting-edge, partnering, collaborative, open, honest, descriptive, visual, explorative, evaluative, ethical are all just some of the words to describe the amazing authors nationally in this arena. It’s always exciting when we are notified of a new submission, and getting to have the first read through the article. So interesting to see how people approach their research, and how truly and consistently innovative the researchers/authors are with their work.

5. Growth in Irish T&L
One element that was very evident from my editorial role’s timeframe was the growth of the T&L space across Ireland. The number of AISHE members, the number of article submissions, the number of people submitting research following their professional development courses or accreditations have all been on the increase. This is testament to the change in the national culture around teaching and learning over the last decade or so, motivated and supported heavily by the National Forum since its inception.

6. Power of Special Issues
Special issues are a real powerhouse of focus, drive and inspiration. They cement the authors, reviewers and editors in a strangely intangible way, with everyone working towards a shared concept, one cementing progress in a particular space. They also provide opportunity for collaboration, whereby the outcome is greater than the sum of its parts. This was very evident with the NStEP and AISHE-J collaboration on student engagement and partnership, which was published in 2022. As part of this issue, we engaged with both student authors and reviewers also, with the latter receiving training and support. Overall, the incredible efforts from staff and students towards this collaborative special issue was something to truly behold.

7. Skills that assist
Like many roles, there’s a process to follow as an editor with submissions, and ensuring you stick to that helps everyone associated, i.e. fellow editors, authors, reviewers as well as any associated admin staff a journal may have. Yes, good communication skills are a must and an eagle eye for detail is often required when reading/proofing submissions, but an overall awareness of the T&L field, or relevant papers in certain spaces, experience of various methodologies, referencing approaches, qualitative research/data analysis etc. combine to assist too. A wide network of potential reviewers does help the review process for editors, while strong technical skills will also assist with article/text/graphic formatting that may be required from time to time. In saying all of the above, it’s attributes such as dedication, kindness, positivity, commitment and empathy which can also hugely complement being an editor too.

8. Ethics, ethics & ethics
If there was one aspect that seems to come to the fore quite often, it stems around ethics. Editors, reviewers both look to ensure that any research studies being submitted gained ethical clearance and/or abided by institutional permissions in the ethics space. If someone is new to research in this area, I would be advising them to try and connect with a colleague who has experience publishing for advice, to line up the ethics applications and permissions before commencing the research and to highlight in their submission the ethical considerations/permissions behind the study being presented. Many authors have approval, but may not mention it in the methodology, so doing this may be worth considering. Finally, do bear in mind if it is a multi-institutional study, and you only have approval from your own institution, you will need approval in each of the others also, i.e. at each location where the research is being carried out with participants. It’s worth being aware of this, as with each institution having its own review committee structures, it can impact timelines and may need to be prioritised (always good if you can have the approval letter from your institution in the application elsewhere also).

9. What will I miss most?

- The joy of telling someone their article has been accepted and will appear in the upcoming issue, a lovely e mail to send.
- Writing the word ‘final’ in the filename that is uploaded to the interface for publication.
- The editorial team meetings and connection with the team members - always fun, always a laugh, always supportive, always productive.
- Having the opportunity to connect with people nationally in the role, be it either authors and reviewers.
- Putting together the intro to some of the editorials, while daunted at first, I actually grew to enjoy this later on. Even managed to squeeze in a quote from my musical hero Bono in to one of them.
All in all, when I think back to when I published my first teaching and learning focused paper in AISHE-J, and how I later ended up being part of the editorial team some years later, I’m very proud to have contributed, supported and invested time and effort to this incredible cause. Being aware of the people associated with both AISHE and AISHE-J since their inception, it’s been a wonderful experience to have sailed those shores on the same boat too for a while.
You can follow AISHE on Twitter (@AISHE_EDU) or if you wish to be a reviewer with AISHE-J, or be considered to join the editorial team, please do send an e mail to info@aishe.org
All good things must come to an end, but I can honestly say I enjoyed my 6-year/3-year AISHE/AISHE-J journeys.
I must acknowledge the amazing co-editors I worked with during my time there...Moira Maguire, Morag Munro, Sylvia Huntley-Moore, Ekaterina Kozina, Saranne Magennis, Brett Becker, Bernadette Brereton and Oisin Hassan. I must acknowledge Moira Maguire in particular, as throughout my time with AISHE-J and in her role as editor-in-chief, she led by example, supported and co-ordinated across several levels and was always the one who pressed 'publish' once everything is in order. Moira's commitment and dedication to AISHE-J has consistently been exemplary.
You can follow AISHE on Twitter (@AISHE_EDU) or if you wish to be a reviewer with AISHE-J, or be considered to join the editorial team, please do send an e mail to info@aishe.org
All good things must come to an end, but I can honestly say I enjoyed my 6-year/3-year AISHE/AISHE-J journeys.
I must acknowledge the amazing co-editors I worked with during my time there...Moira Maguire, Morag Munro, Sylvia Huntley-Moore, Ekaterina Kozina, Saranne Magennis, Brett Becker, Bernadette Brereton and Oisin Hassan. I must acknowledge Moira Maguire in particular, as throughout my time with AISHE-J and in her role as editor-in-chief, she led by example, supported and co-ordinated across several levels and was always the one who pressed 'publish' once everything is in order. Moira's commitment and dedication to AISHE-J has consistently been exemplary.